St Croix is the cheapest of the three main USVI islands at $3,600 per person per month at the moderate tier, roughly $375 cheaper than St Thomas ($3,975). St John (the third island) does not have its own dedicated CostLiving page but is the most expensive of the three for housing thanks to limited inventory and a high share of luxury and short-term-rental stock; long-term rentals routinely match or exceed St Thomas levels. The cost gap between St Croix and St Thomas is overwhelmingly driven by housing: a comparable one-bedroom on St Croix typically runs $400 to $800 a month less than on St Thomas. Utilities, groceries, and transport are broadly similar across the territory. For the full breakdown, see our St Croix cost of living page.
๐ด
What is the cheapest US Virgin Island to live on?
Region Caribbean
Updated July 2026